Writs in the Indian Constitution

Writ petition before the Supreme Court is an application for enforcement of Fundamental Rights under Article 32 of the Indian Constitution, 1950. It is a last judicial resort available before a person for seeking remedy. Curative petition can be against any judgment or decision of Supreme Court. Under Article 137 Supreme Court has the ability to review its own Judgments, subject to some rules made under the provisions of Article 145 as given under the provisions of article only.

We have successfully worked with over 5 lakh customers, and have now registered over 10% of all the companies registered in India. For more on certiorari, see this Harvard Law Review article and this University of Michigan https://1investing.in/ Law Review article. Writs have validity only in the territory under the authority of the High Court or where the cause of action has arisen. Issued to executive authorities or government machinery, bound to do some act.

  • Issued to inferior courts, tribunals or to any judicial or quasi-judicial body.
  • However, in Maryland v. Baltimore Radio Show, Inc., 338 U.S. 912 (1950), the Court explained that because of practical considerations (such as allowing the Court to carry out its duties), Congress has allowed the control of the Court’s business to remain within the Court’s discretion.
  • However, in some specific cases, an application of Habeas Corpus can be filed by any person, other than the one detained, on his behalf i.e., friend or relative.
  • Just upload your form 16, claim your deductions and get your acknowledgment number online.

Any judicial entity as “subject to bias” when he is in favour or against any party to the dispute or where it can be assumed that bias exist then he should not take part in the decision. Also where there exists any pecuniary interest(or any other interest) of the person sitting to provide justice to all will become reason for his disqualification in giving decision in that case. Further a sub- rule to this principle states that every decision of tribunal must be accompanied with a reason for giving such decision whereas this rule does not apply in English Common- Law. And in India also this rule is not a universally established rule though in certain cases in rigidly followed.

Where to file a suit if writ petition has been dismissed in high court

This right can be availed by any person whose fundamental rights are violated. When a lawsuit is filed, it moves through a series of stages before it is finally resolved. In civil cases, the first stage is the filing of a petition or a complaint by the plaintiff stating the legal basis for the lawsuit. The defendant receives a copy of the document and a notice to appear in court.

  • It was held by the court that his infringement of fundamental right under Article 19(1)(g) was entitled to relief under Article 226 of the Constitution.
  • A lawyer can guide you with the place of filing and can also help you with the filing while saving you from the tedious process of applying to court.
  • In those jurisdictions, the term “Petition” is often used to refer to court cases that aren’t governed by the ordinary rules of civil procedure.
  • This document was only issued after the summons from the sheriff to comply deemed fruitful.
  • However, in certain specific circumstances, anyone else—a friend or relative—can apply for a writ of habeas corpus on behalf of the person who is being held.

When it comes to petitions for writ of certiorari, the Supreme Court gets many but grants few. For example, of the 8,241 petitions filed during its 2009 term, the Court granted only 91, or about 1.1 percent. Any individual person or a private body can file Writ Petition under mandamus.

Therefore, the appeal was dismissed by the court and writ of mandamus was not issued. Prohibition writ for the court is issued to stop or put a stay on the power exercised by the authority and is commonly known as stay order. In India, a writ petition is issued against the proceedings going on in lower courts and in such proceeding, the lower court is exceeding its powers.

Writ Petition Filed against Mumbai University

Facts- Respondent no.1 is an education society of bombay running as a recognised Anglo- Indian School named Barnes High School at Deolali. Petitioner filed an appeal but the same was dismissed by the commissioner of police as he felt himself competitive enough to deal with it. As a general principle it is stated that if there is any unreasonable delay in  seeking for this extraordinary remedy then, remedy of mandamus may not be made available. Hence, all the writs can be called as order but all order can’t be called writs, because  the ambit of order is larger than writs. The term complaint is more often used in litigation, although legislation also refers to “filing suit”. Criminal law practice uses the term “Complaint” differently than in civil practice, however.

Difference between Lawyer and Advocate

Where a plaintiff wished to have a case heard by a local court or by the justice of an Eyre if one happened to be visiting the county, there would be no need to obtain a writ. However, if a plaintiff wished to avail himself of Royal — and by implication superior — justice in one of the King’s courts, then he would need a writ, a command of the King, to enable him to do this. Initially, for common law, recourse to the King’s courts was unusual, and something for which a plaintiff would have to pay. For most Royal Courts, the writ would usually have been purchased from the Chancery, although the court of the Exchequer, being, in essence, another government department, could issue its own writs.

How to File a Writ Petition: Steps & Sample Drafts

These writs are useful when people are imprisoned for long periods of time before they’re actually convicted or charged with a crime. The writ of certiorari, on the other hand, is used by the U.S. federal courts. This writ is issued by the Supreme Court of the United States to a lower court to review that court’s judgment for legal error or when no other avenue for appeal is available. Arguably the most common use of that term is when asking the court to issue a Personal Protection Order, aka a Restraining Order. In the top court of a jurisdiction, the term almost always refers to an appeal.

It was held by Lord Atkin, justice of the Supreme Court of Nigeria, that issuance of a writ of habeas corpus must be followed by proper procedure. The subject has the right to question the validity of his detention again and again by moving an application before different judges for the same facts and it became the duty of the court to guard the freedom of the subject. Supreme Court declares that an application for the writ of habeas corpus can be filed by the person illegally jailed or can also be filed by any other person on his behalf provided that such any person must not be totally a stranger to the person wrongfully detained. Writ of habeas corpus is a powerful weapon available before a common man who has been wrongfully detained by the person or state.

Petitions vs. Complaints

Issued to inferior courts, tribunals or to any judicial or quasi-judicial body. Issued to quash the order passed by the inferior courts or tribunals in excess of jurisdiction. It says that when the same question has been decided by the High Court under Article 226 and conclude the matter with an order that no relief is granted to the petitioner then such decision of the High Court act as res judicata in subsequent petitions for similar relief.

Article 137 impose power on Supreme court to review any of the judgment or order pronounced by it. Answering to the question Court held that in order to prevent abuse of procedure nad law and cure the gross coducted by miscarriage of justice, the Supereme Court has reconsidered its Power for this purpose, and therefore, discovered this new concept of curative petiton. Command given to government, court, corporation or public authority to do or not to do some specific act.

Writ jurisdiction is exercised to control the vast discretionary power of administrative authorities as those powers become subjects in the absence of guidelines for exercising those powers. To ensure that “rule of law” exists in all the government action, there arises a need to control the discretionary powers of administrative authorities. Judicial review of administrative actions is important to ensure that all the actions taken by the administrative authorities are legal, rational, fair, just and as per the provisions of law.

According to supreme court rules, 2013 review petition needs to be filled within 30 days from the date of judgment or order. It is urged that direction given by Executive Council to re-organisation of governing bodies of non-governmental colleges constitutes infringement of the fundamental rights of the governing body of Bholanath college on Linguistic minorities under article 30 clause(1) of Indian Constitution, 1950. Also it was argued that the scheme introduced by the Executive Council is ultra vires of the university.

You must log in to answer this question.

A writ petition is a plea before any higher court for extraordinary review. Person seeking writ petition requests the court to intervene in the decisions of inferior courts. The petitioner in this case has deliberately given misstatement of facts in his petition application with an intention to mislead the court and on the same misstatement obtained a rules of nisi prohibiting the state from taking certain actions. Misstatement by the petitioner is itself a sufficient ground for refusing the writ petition.whereas, a mere mistake in the name of the parties by the person filing the petition does not affect its maintainability. Therefore, Allahabad High Court held that the alternate remedy available before the petitioner is not an adequate one hence, writ jurisdiction can’t be refused and he can seek relief by way of writ petition under Article 226. Writ of Mandamus that appeared in earlier law books was not concerned about private grievances at all.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *